the Institute of Development Studies and partner organisations
Browse
- No file added yet -

Encouraging ‘Returns’, Obstructing Departures and Constructing Causal Links: The New Creed of Euro-African Migration Management

Download (790.98 kB)
online resource
posted on 2024-09-05, 22:11 authored by Marie-Dominique Aguillon
This paper explores whether the policy level constitutes a new element in what Hernández-León coined as “the migration industry” in 2005. The paper unravels the impact of semantic and legal shifts at different scales over the past two decades on the framing of irregular migration. Several key moments have marked Euro-African relations in the field migration. Through the decoding of political exchanges between African and European actors, this article shows the predominant objectives of migration policies. The first aims to encourage "returns" of migrants from Europe to Africa. The second seeks to dissuade potential African candidates from leaving (implied towards Europe), and the third presupposes that the returns of some migrants will make potential migrants renounce the journey. In order to prevent departures and to justify returns, new causal links appear in speeches. There is here an idea of an archetypal model linking returns and deterrents. This binary justification of a presupposed causality between returns and departures is questionable however because evidence shows that returns will not necessarily have the expected deterrent effect. Nevertheless, the migration and development nexus has gradually come to complement the migration and security nexus. At different scales and through semantic and legal shifts, emigration has been framed as a “problem” then as a “crime” in the dominant policy discourse. Through the design and implementation of departure deterrence programmes, actors from NGOs, international organisations, political institutions and the media are strengthening the controversial notion of "illegal emigration" which, gradually, has become a new resource in the field of migration management.

Funding

DFID

History

Publisher

Migrating out of Poverty

IDS Item Types

Other

Copyright holder

University of Sussex

Country

Senegal

Language

en

Usage metrics

    Migrating out of Poverty - Working Papers

    Categories

    No categories selected

    Exports

    RefWorks
    BibTeX
    Ref. manager
    Endnote
    DataCite
    NLM
    DC